349x Filetype XLSX File size 0.62 MB Source: mentor.ieee.org
CID Commenter LB Draf Clause Page(C) Line(C) Type of Part of
Number(C) Comment No Vote
3049Alecsander 249 29.6.7.48 96 9 E Y
Eitan
3069Alecsander 249 211.22.6.4.6.2 158 41 E Y
Eitan
3073Alecsander 249 227.3.17c 205 16 E Y
Eitan
3075Alecsander 249 227.3.17c 208 9 E Y
Eitan
3096Alecsander 249 2AD 240 9 E Y
Eitan
3205Assaf Kasher 249 29.4.2.296 72 6 E Y
3297Erik Lindskog 249 211.22.6.4.8.4 169 28 E Y
3298Erik Lindskog 249 211.22.6.4.8.3 166 26 E Y
3486Mark RISON 249 2 E Y
3487Mark RISON 249 227.3.17c E Y
3542Mark RISON 249 211.22.6.3.2 117 11 E Y
3769Mark RISON 249 211.22.6.4.6.2 158 41 E Y
3781Mark RISON 249 211.22.6.4.6.3 163 E Y
3953Stephan Sand 249 29.4.2.21.10 54 6 E N
Page Line Clause Duplicate Resn Comment
of CID Status
96.009 9.6.7.48 Equation in non standard format
158.0041 11.22.6.4.6.2 Equation in non standard format
205.0016 27.3.17c Text in non-standard format
208.009 27.3.17c Equation in non standard format
240.009 AD Equation in non standard format in
annex AD
72.006 9.4.2.296 In the last row fo the figure/table -
make columns wider
169.0028 11.22.6.4.8.4 In Figure 11-36u (Passive TB
Ranging measurement reporting
phase), we are using some proxies
for the 'RSTA-to-ISTA LMR frame'
and for the 'LMR from ISTA to RSTA'
frames. We may want to consider
changing to using the proper frame
names here.
166.0026 11.22.6.4.8.3 In Figure 11-36s (Passive TB Ranging
polling, measurement sounding,
and
27 measurement reporting phases),
we are using some proxy names for
some the frames. We may want to
consider changing to using the
proper frame names here.
Equations seem to be graphics.
They need to be text, so that they
can be searched
27.3.17c Equations seem to be graphics.
They need to be text, so that they
can be searched
117.0011 11.22.6.3.2 "NOTE -- The use of phase relations,
per Subclauses 19.3.11.11.4
("Transmission in 40 MHz HT 11
format") and 21.3.7.5 ("Definition
of tone rotation"), between the
20 MHz parts in non-HT 12
duplicate PPDUs that contain Ack
frames transmitted by the initiating
STA is required to enable 13
the responding STA to accurately
determine the TOA of these frames,
and is thus required for the 14
initiating STA to support FTM
using Ack frames transmitted in
non-HT duplicate PPDUs. 15
Alternatively, an ISTA that supports
transmission of VHT or HT Ack
frame as a control response 16
frame to the FTM transmissions
sent by RSTA in VHT or HT format
respectively, is not required 17
to support the non-HT duplicate
PPDU Ack frame for FTM
transmissions. (#1516) " needs to be
clearer
158.0041 11.22.6.4.6.2 This equation gives me 1980s
Macintosh vibes
163.00 11.22.6.4.6.3 More 80s typesetting!
54.006 9.4.2.21.10 The editing instruction reads "Insert
the following new paragraphs after
the NOTE as shown below
(#1347):", but some new
paragraphs are inserted before the
"NOTE"
no reviews yet
Please Login to review.