jagomart
digital resources
picture1_Enteral Nutrition Pdf 135047 | Jce80032


 140x       Filetype PDF       File size 0.16 MB       Source: jamanetwork.com


File: Enteral Nutrition Pdf 135047 | Jce80032
caring for the critically ill patient total parenteral nutrition in the critically ill patient ameta analysis daren k heyland md frcpc msc shaun macdonald md frcsc laurie keefe rd john ...

icon picture PDF Filetype PDF | Posted on 04 Jan 2023 | 2 years ago
Partial capture of text on file.
                   Caring for the Critically Ill Patient
                   Total Parenteral Nutrition
                   in the Critically Ill Patient
                   AMeta-analysis
                   Daren K. Heyland, MD, FRCPC, MSc; Shaun MacDonald MD, FRCSC;
                   Laurie Keefe, RD; John W. Drover, MD, FRCSC
                      Context.—Nutritional support has become a standard of care for hospitalized                                barrier structure and function, aug-
                   patients, but whether total parenteral nutrition (TPN) affects morbidity and mortality                        menting the inflammatory response to
                   is unclear.                                                                                                   illnessandresultingingreaterinfectious
                      Objective.—To examine the relationship between TPN and complication and                                    morbidity.3-5 As a consequence, nutri-
                   mortality rates in critically ill patients.                                                                   tional supporthasbecomeastandardof
                      DataSources.—ComputerizedsearchofpublishedresearchonMEDLINEfrom                                            care for hospitalized patients.
                   1980 to 1998, personal files, and review of relevant reference lists.                                             Because intestinal stimulation from
                      Study Selection.—We reviewed 210 titles, abstracts, and papers. Primary                                    luminalnutrientshelpsmaintaingastro-
                                                                                                                                 intestinal mucosal structure and func-
                   studies were included if they were randomized clinical trials of critically ill or surgi-                     tion,6-9 enteral nutrition may have some
                   cal patients that evaluated the effect of TPN (compared with standard care) on                                advantage over total parenteral nutri-
                   complicationandmortalityrates.WeexcludedstudiescomparingTPNwithenteral                                        tion (TPN). Compared with TPN, ran-
                   nutrition.                                                                                                    domized trials of critically ill patients
                      DataExtraction.—Relevantdatawereabstractedonthemethodologyandout-                                          have demonstrated that enteral nutri-
                   comes of primary studies. Data were abstracted in duplicate, independently.                                   tion administered within the first 24
                      DataSynthesis.—Therewere26randomizedtrialsof2211patientscomparing                                          hoursofadmissiontotheintensivecare
                   the use of TPN with standard care (usual oral diet plus intravenous dextrose) in                              unit(ICU)resultsinbetterwoundheal-
                                                                                                                                      10
                   surgical and critically ill patients. When the results of these trials were aggregated,                       ing, adecreaseingastrointestinaltract
                                                                                                                                                             11
                                                                                                                                 mucosalpermeability, andlowerinfec-
                   TPNhadnoeffectonmortality (risk ratio [RR], 1.03; 95% confidence interval [CI],                                             12-14
                   0.81-1.31). Patients who received TPN tended to have a lower complication rate,                               tion rates.        Where possible, enteral
                                                                                                                                 feeding is preferred to parenteral feed-
                   butthisresultwasnotstatisticallysignificant(RR,0.84;95%CI,0.64-1.09).Weex-                                          15
                                                                                                                                 ing.   However, some patients with an
                   aminedseveralapriori hypotheses and found that studies including only malnour-                                intact gastrointestinal tract do not tol-
                   ished patients were associated with lower complication rates but no difference in                             erateenteralfeedsordonotreceivesuf-
                   mortality when compared with studies of nonmalnourished patients. Studies pub-                                ficientintakeenterallyororallytomeet
                   lished since 1989 and studies with a higher methods score showed no treatment                                 their energy and protein requirements.
                   effect, while studies published in 1988 or before and studies with a lower methods                            Total parenteral nutrition is used as a
                   score demonstrated a significant treatment effect. Complication rates were lower                               supplement or as the sole source of nu-
                                                                                                                                 trition in these patients16,17
                   in studies that did not use lipids; however, there was no difference in mortality rates                                                           ; however,
                                                                                                                                 previousevidencesupportingthisprac-
                   between studies that did not use lipids and those studies that did. Studies limited                           tice seems to be lacking.18,19 Since these
                   to critically ill patients demonstrated a significant increase in complication and mor-                                                                 19
                   tality rates compared with studies of surgical patients.                                                      studies were reviewed in 1987,              addi-
                                                                                                                                 tional randomizedtrialshavebeenpub-
                      Conclusions.—Total parenteral nutrition does not influence the overall mortal-                              lished. The purpose of this article is to
                   ity rate of surgical or critically ill patients. It may reduce the complication rate, es-                     review systematically, appraise criti-
                   pecially in malnourished patients, but study results are influenced by patient popu-                           cally,andaggregatestatisticallystudies
                   lation, use of lipids, methodological quality, and year of publication.                                       evaluatingtheeffectofTPNincritically
                                                                                                 JAMA.1998;280:2013-2019         ill patients.
                     FromtheDepartmentsofMedicine(DrsHeylandand           MALNUTRITIONamonghospitalized                          METHODS
                   MacDonald)andSurgery(DrDrover),Queen’sUniver-          patients has been associated with in-                  Search Strategy
                   sityandNutritionalServices,KingstonGeneralHospital     creased morbidity, prolonged hospital                     Weconductedacomputerizedbiblio-
                   (Ms Keefe), Kingston, Ontario.                                                                                graphicsearchofMEDLINE(including
                     DrHeylandisaCareerScientistoftheOntarioMinis-        stay, and increased costs to the health
                   try of Health.                                         care system.1,2 Several studies have                   pre-MEDLINE) for studies from 1980
                     Reprints:DarenK.Heyland,MD,FRCPC,MSc,Angada          documentedthat“bowelrest”isassoci-                     to April 1998 to locate all relevant ar-
                   3, KingstonGeneralHospital,76StuartSt,Kingston,On-     ated with a disruption of the mucosal                  ticles.Thetermsrandomizedcontrolled
                   tario, Canada K7L 2V7 (e-mail: dkh@post.queensu.ca).
                   JAMA, December 16, 1998—Vol 280, No. 23                                            Total Parenteral Nutrition in the Critically Ill Patient—Heyland et al 2013
                                                                   ©1998AmericanMedicalAssociation. All rights reserved.
    Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 01/04/2023
                     Table 1.—Criteria Used to Assess Methodologic Quality*                                                                blinding the administration of TPN, we
                                                                                         Score                                             only awarded points for studies that
                                                                                                                                           blinded the adjudication of study end
                                                             012
                                                                                                                                           points. We also evaluated the extent to
                     Randomization                          . . .             Not concealed                 Concealed randomization        which consecutive, eligible patients
                                                                                or not sure                                                were enrolled in the trial, whether
                     Blinding                      Not blinded                          . . .               Adjudicators blinded           groupswereequalatbaseline,ifcointer-
                     Analysis                      Other                                . . .               Intention to treat             ventions were adequately described,
                     Patient selection             Selected patients or       Consecutive eligible                     ...                 whether objective definitions of infec-
                                                     unable to tell             patients                                                   tious outcomeswereused,andwhether
                     Comparability of groups       No or not sure             Yes                                       . . .              all patientswereproperlyaccountedfor
                        at baseline
                     Extent of follow-up           ,100%                      100%                                     . . .               intheanalysis(intention-to-treatanaly-
                     Treatment protocol            Poorly described           Reproducibly described                    . . .              sis) (Table 1).
                     Cointerventions†              Not described              Described but not equal       Well described and
                                                                                or not sure                   all equal                    Data Extraction
                     Outcomes                      Not described              Partially described           Objectively defined                Twoofus(D.K.H.andS.M.)extracted
                       *The first 3 questions and the last 2 questions had a possible score of 0, 1, or 2. The middle 3 questions had a     data for analysis and assessment of the
                     possible score of 0 or 1. The highest possible score was 14. Ellipses indicate data not applicable.                   methodologic quality; we resolved dis-
                       †Theextenttowhichantibiotics,enteralnutrition,ventilation,oxygen,andtransfusionswereappliedequallyacross            agreementbyconsensus.Notallstudies
                     groups.                                                                                                               reportedcomplicationrates.Somestud-
                     trial,doubleblindmethod,clinicaltrial,                     differences that might exist between                       ies reported total complications per
                     placebo, and comparative study were                        thesepatientsinthesubgroupanalysis.                        group but not on a per-patient basis.
                     combined with explode parenteral nu-                       Weexcludedstudiesofpediatricorneo-                         Whendataweremissing,unclear,ornot
                     trition, total. Citations were limited to                  natal patients.                                            reported on a per-patient basis, we at-
                     English-language studies reporting on                         Weincluded only studies that evalu-                     temptedtocontacttheprimaryinvesti-
                     adult patients. Reference lists of rel-                    atedtheuseofsupplementalTPNinpa-                           gators and requested them to provide
                     evant review articles and personal files                   tientsreceivingenteralfeedsorstudies                       further information if the article had
                     werealsosearched.                                          evaluating the use of TPN in patients                      beenpublishedinthelast5years.
                     Study Selection Criteria                                   whowerenotreceivingTPNorenteral                            Prior Hypotheses Regarding Sources
                                                                                nutrition.Thereareseveralrandomized                        of Heterogeneity
                        Initially, 2 of us (D.K.H. and S.M.)                    trials of surgical patients that examine
                     screenedallcitationsandclassifiedthem                      theeffectofaminoacidinfusion(without                          When conducting a systematic re-
                     as primary studies, review articles, or                    additional nonprotein energy or lipids)                    view, heterogeneity (major differences
                     other. We then retrieved and reviewed                      onclinicaloutcomes.Suchtherapyisnot                        in the apparent effect of the interven-
                     independently all primary studies. Pri-                    astandardofcareinthecriticallyillpa-                       tions across studies) is often found.
                     marystudieswereselectedforinclusion                        tient,whereasTPN(withorwithoutlip-                         Whenheterogeneityispresent,itweak-
                     in this overview if the study’s (1) re-                    ids) is commonly administered to criti-                    ensinferencesthatcanbemadefromthe
                     searchdesignwasarandomizedclinical                         callyill patients. Forthepurposeofthis                     results. The possible sources of varia-
                     trial; (2) populationconsistedofsurgical                   review, we excluded studies that used                      tion in study results include the role of
                     orcritically ill human adult subjects; (3)                 only amino acid infusions as the inter-                    chance or differences across studies in
                     intervention included any form of TPN                      vention.Asthescopeofourreviewwas                           population, intervention, outcome, and
                     (protein, source of nonprotein energy                      definedbyourresearchquestion,wealso                        methods.Wedevelopedseveralhypoth-
                     with or without lipids) compared with                      excluded studies that compared TPN                         esesthatmightexplainheterogeneityof
                     standardcare(oraldietplusintravenous                       with enteral nutrition or other forms of                   studyresults.
                     fluids); and (4) outcome measures in-                      TPN.Finally,studiesthatevaluatedthe                           First,weconsideredthatthepremor-
                     cludedcomplications,lengthofstay,and                       impact of TPN only on nutritional out-                     bid nutritional status of study patients
                     mortality.                                                 comes (ie, nitrogen balance, amino acid                    was a possible cause of variation in re-
                        Becausestudiesinwhichtreatmentis                        profile)werenotincludedinthisarticle.                      sults. Where possible, we grouped the
                     allocated in any method other than ran-                    Whiletheseendpointsmayexplainun-                           results of studies that included only pa-
                     domizationtendtoshowlarger(andfre-                         derlying pathophysiology, we consid-                       tientswhoweremalnourishedandcom-
                     quentlyfalse-positive)treatmenteffects                     eredtheseassurrogateendpoints23and                         pared them with the results of studies
                     than do randomized trials,20 we elected                    weonly included articles that reported                     thatincludedpatientswhowerenotmal-
                     to include only randomized trials in this                  on clinically important outcomes (mor-                     nourished at entrance into the study.
                     review.Wedefinedcriticallyillpatients                      bidity and mortality).                                     Whenpossible,weusedthedefinitionof
                     as those who would routinely be cared                      Methodologic Quality                                       malnourishedprovidedineachstudy.If
                     for in a critical care environment. Pa-                    of Primary Studies                                         nonewasprovided,weassumedpatients
                     tients undergoing major surgery may                                                                                   whohadgreaterthan10%weightlossto
                     notalwaysbecaredforinacriticalcare                            Weassessedthemethodologicquality                        bemalnourished.
                     environment but share similarities in                      ofallselectedarticlesinduplicate,inde-                        Second, we hypothesized that study
                     their response to illness, a hypercata-                    pendently, using a scoring system that                     results may be related to the methodo-
                     bolicstatecharacterizedbyweightloss,                       we have used previously24 (Table 1).                       logic quality of the study. We planned a
                     loss of body fat, and accelerated break-                   Eveninrandomizedtrials,failuretopre-                       separate analysis comparing the effect
                     down of body proteins.21 Previous sys-                     vent foreknowledge of treatment as-                        of studies with an overall methodologic
                     tematicreviewshaveincorporateddata                         signmentcanleadtoanoverestimation                          quality score to those with a score less
                     from surgical patients and critically ill                  of treatment effect.25 Accordingly, we                     than7(medianscore,7).
                                 15,22                                                                                                        Third, since the practice of providing
                     patients.       Therefore,weoptedtocom-                    scored higher those studies that re-
                     bine studies of surgical patients and                      portedthattheirrandomizationschema                         nutritional support and managing criti-
                     critically ill patients and to explore any                 was concealed. Given the difficulties of                   cally ill patients has evolved over time
                     2014 JAMA,December16,1998—Vol280,No.23                                                             Total Parenteral Nutrition in the Critically Ill Patient—Heyland et al
                                                                        ©1998AmericanMedicalAssociation. All rights reserved.
    Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 01/04/2023
                   (included studies range from 1976 to                    withbiasandinstabilityassociatedwith                       Tobetterunderstandourfindings,we
                   1997), we divided the studies into equal                RRestimationinsparsedata,weadded                        proceeded to examine our a priori hy-
                   groups comparing studies published in                   onehalftoeachcell.35Inthemeta-analy-                    potheses. We compared trials that in-
                   1988 or earlier with studies published                  sis, we used maximum likelihood meth-                   cludedonlymalnourishedpatientswith
                   since 1989 (halfway point of the study                  odsofcombiningRRacrossalltrialsand                      other trials. No difference in mortality
                   range).                                                 examined the data for evidence of het-                  existed(Figure3)forstudiesofmalnour-
                                                                                                            36
                      Fourth, since some studies adminis-                  erogeneitywithingroups. TheMantel-                      ished patients (RR, 1.13; 95% CI, 0.75-
                   tered amino acids and a carbohydrate                    Haenszel37 method was used to test the                  1.71) or in studies that included ad-
                   source of energy while others adminis-                  significanceoftreatmenteffect.Weused                    equately nourished patients (RR, 1.00;
                   tered amino acids, carbohydrates, and                   a random effects model to estimate the                  95%CI,0.71-1.39;P=.64fordifferences
                   lipids,weseparatedtrialsintothosethat                   overallRR.38,39Forthetestofheteroge-                    between subgroups). The rate of major
                   included lipids and those without. We                   neity across subgroups, we used the t                   complications was significantly lower
                   hypothesizedthattheremaybeadverse                       testforthedifferencebetweenthe2sub-                     amongmalnourishedpatientsreceiving
                                                      26
                   effects caused by lipid use.                            groups.WeconsideredP,.05tobesta-                        TPN(RR, 0.52; 95% CI, 0.30-0.91). No
                      Finally, we speculated that differ-                  tistically significant.                                 difference existed in complication rates
                   encesinpatientpopulations(surgicalvs                                                                            amongstudies of adequately nourished
                   critically ill) may account for different               RESULTS                                                 patients (RR, 1.02; 95% CI, 0.75-1.40).
                   results. To test this hypothesis, we                    Study Identification and Selection                       Thedifferenceincomplicationratesbe-
                   planned a separate analysis comparing                                                                           tween these subgroups was of border-
                   studiesofsurgicalpatientswithstudies                       Atotalof153citationswereidentified                   line significance (P=.05).
                   of critically ill patients.                             through a computerized bibliographic                       Wecomparedtrials with a methodo-
                   Analysis                                                database search. Our personal files and                 logicqualityscoreoflessthan7withtri-
                                                                           review of reference lists yielded 57 ad-                alswithascoreof7orbetter(Figure3).
                      The primary outcome was periopera-                   ditionalarticlesforconsideration.Initial                Trials with the higher methods score
                   tivemortality(deathwithin30daysofop-                    eligibility screening resulted in 46 ar-                demonstratednoeffectofTPNonmor-
                   eration) or mortality reported at dis-                  ticles selectedforfurtherevaluation.Of                  tality (RR, 1.17; 95% CI, 0.88-1.56). We
                   charge from hospital. The secondary                     thesepotentiallyeligiblestudies,26met                   noted a trend toward a lower mortality
                   outcomewastherateofmajorcomplica-                       the inclusion criteria.                                 rate in studies with a lower methods
                   tions.Wedefinedmajorcomplicationsas                        Wereached100%agreementonthein-                       score (RR, 0.76; 95% CI, 0.49-1.19). The
                   pneumonia,intra-abdominalabscess,sep-                   clusion of articles for this systematic re-             difference between these 2 subgroups
                   sis,linesepsis,myocardialinfarction,pul-                view.Reasonsforexcludingrelevantran-                    was short of conventional levels of sig-
                   monaryemboli,heartfailure, stroke, re-                  domized studies included studies not                    nificance (P=.12). Withrespecttocom-
                                                                           generalizable to critically ill patients40
                   nalfailure, liver failure, and anastomotic                                                                ;     plication rates, studies with a higher
                   leak.Minorcomplicationsweredefinedas                    studies that evaluated different kinds of               methods score demonstrated no treat-
                   woundinfection, phlebitis, urinary tract                TPN41-43;studiesthatevaluatedaminoac-                   menteffect(RR,1.13;95%CI,0.86-1.50).
                   infection,andatelectasis.In4studies,the                 ids only44-47; pseudorandomized studies                 Studies with a lower methods score
                   datawerenotportrayedinafashionthat                      (not true randomization)48-52; studies du-              showed a significant reduction in com-
                   allowed us to report major complication                 plicated in other publications34,53,54; stud-           plication rates associated with TPN
                   rates, so we reported total compli-                     iesnotreportingclinicallyimportantout-                  (RR,0.54;95%CI,0.33-0.87).Thediffer-
                            27-29                                                  55-57                                           enceincomplicationratesbetweenthese
                   cations       and total infectious complica-            comes       ; studies available in abstract
                   tions.30 Reporting methods of individual                formonly58;andastudythatalsorandom-                     subgroupswassignificant (P=.02).
                   studies did not allow us to disaggregate                ized patients to anabolic steroids.59                      Wenextcomparedtrialspublishedin
                   infectious from noninfectious complica-                                                                         1988 or earlier with trials published in
                   tions.Onestudy31randomizedpatientsto                    Impact of TPN on Mortality                              1989orlater(Figure3).Trialspublished
                   3 groups (control vs standard TPN vs                    and Complications Rates                                 in 1988 or earlier demonstrated a trend
                   TPNwithbranch-chainaminoacids).We                          Thereare26randomizedtrialsinvolv-                    towardalowermortalityrateassociated
                   onlyincludeddatafromthecontrolgroup                     ing2211patientsthatcomparetheuseof                      withTPN(RR,0.70;95%CI,0.44-1.13).
                   andthestandardTPNgroup.Twoother                         TPNwithstandard care (usual oral diet                   Trials published since 1989 demon-
                   studies randomized patients to 3 groups                 plusintravenousfluids)inpatientsunder-                  strated no treatment effect (RR, 1.18;
                   (control vs TPN without lipids vs TPN                   going surgery,27-34,60-74 patients with pan-            95%CI,0.89-1.57).Differencesbetween
                   withlipids),andweincludedbothexperi-                    creatitis,75 patients in an intensive care              these2subgroupswereshortofconven-
                   mental groups in the analysis.32-34 One                 unit,76 and patients with severe burns.77               tional levels of statistical significance
                   study included reports of 2 trials.34 The               The details of each study, including the                (P=.07).Thereweresignificantlyfewer
                   secondtrialwaspresumedtoincludepa-                      methodologicqualityscore,aredescribed                   major complications associated with
                   tients from the first trial and was there-              inTable2.Whentheresultsofthesetrials                    TPNreportedinstudiesthatwerepub-
                   foreexcluded.Wealsoreportedondura-                      wereaggregated, there was no effect on                  lished in 1988 or earlier (RR, 0.49; 95%
                   tionofhospitalstay,althoughthesedata                    mortality (RR, 1.03; 95% CI, 0.81-1.31)                 CI,0.29-0.81),whileinstudiespublished
                   were not aggregated because of infre-                   (Figure1).Thetestforheterogeneitywas                    since1989therewasnoeffectofTPNon
                   quentandvariablereportingmethods.                       notsignificant(P=.59),althoughavisual                   complication rates (RR, 1.19; 95% CI,
                      Agreementbetweenreviewersonin-                       inspection of Figure 1 suggests that the                0.93-1.53).ThePvalueforthedifference
                   clusion of articles was measured by k                   treatmenteffects are variable.                          between these subgroups was signifi-
                   withquadratic weights.                                     Twenty-two studies reported major                    cant (P=.005).
                      Wecombineddatafromallstudiesto                       complications in study patients. Aggre-                    Wethen compared studies that pro-
                   estimate the common relative risk of                    gation of these results revealed a trend                videdintravenouslipidsasacomponent
                   mortality and complications and associ-                 toward reducing complication rates in                   ofTPNadministrationwithstudiesthat
                   ated95%confidenceintervals(CIs).We                      patients receiving TPN (RR, 0.84; 95%                   did not include lipids. In studies that
                   summarized the treatment effect using                   CI,0.64-1.09)(Figure2).Thetestforhet-                   usedlipids(RR,1.03;95%CI,0.78-1.36)
                   risk ratios (RRs). To avoid the problem                 erogeneity was significant (P=.003).                    and studies that did not (RR, 0.98; 95%
                   JAMA, December 16, 1998—Vol 280, No. 23                                             Total Parenteral Nutrition in the Critically Ill Patient—Heyland et al   2015
                                                                    ©1998AmericanMedicalAssociation. All rights reserved.
    Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 01/04/2023
                        Table 2.—Randomized Studies Evaluating Total Parenteral Nutrition (TPN) in Critically Ill Patients*
                                                                                                                                                  %of
                                                                    Methods                                                                  Malnourished
                                   Source, y                         Score                     Patient Population (No.)                         Patients                                    Intervention
                                           27
                        Veterans Affairs,    1991                       10               Thoracoabdominal surgery (395)                            100                  TPNwith lipids 14 d before surgery
                                   28
                        Fan et al,   1989                               10               Esophageal cancer surgery (40)                              75                 TPNwith lipids 7-15 d before surgery
                                        29
                        Figueras et al,    1988                          7               Gastrointestinal surgery (49)                                0                 TPNwithout lipids after surgery
                                           30
                        Sandstrom et al,      1993                      10               Major surgery/trauma (300)                                  22                 TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                     31
                        Reilly et al,  1990                              7               Liver transplant (18)                                     100                  TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                      32
                        Hwang et al,     1993a§                          5               Gastric surgery (42)                                      . . .                TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                      32
                        Hwang et al,     1993b§                          5               Gastric surgery (42)                                      . . .                TPNwithout lipids after surgery
                                     33
                        Muller et al,   1982                             3               Gastrointestinal surgery (125)                              60                 TPNwithout lipids 10 d before surgery
                                     34
                        Muller et al,   1986                             4               Gastrointestinal surgery (105)                            . . .                TPNwith lipids 10 d before surgery
                                        60
                        Jimenez et al,     1986                          5               Gastrointestinal surgery (75)                             100                  TPNwithout lipids after surgery
                                        61
                        Brennan et al,     1994                          8               Pancreatic resection (117)                                . . .                TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                         62
                        Askanazi et al,    1986                          3               Radical cystectomy (35)                                   . . .                TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                           63
                        Thompson et al,      1981                        4               Gastrointestinal surgery (21)                             100                  TPNwithout lipids 5 d before surgery
                                   64
                        Fan et al,   1994                                7               Hepatocellular cancer surgery (124)                         26                 TPNwith lipids 7 d before surgery
                                    65
                        Abel et al,   1976                               4               Cardiac surgery (44)                                      100                  TPNwithout lipids after surgery
                                         66
                        Bellatone et al,    1988                         6               Gastrointestinal surgery (100)                            100                  TPNwith lipids 7 d before surgery
                                                 67
                        Smith and Hartemink,        1988                 7               Gastrointestinal surgery (34)                             100                  TPNwithout lipids 10 d before surgery
                        Holter and Fischer,68 1977                       5               Gastrointestinal surgery (56)                             100                  TPNwithout lipids 3 d before surgery
                                       69
                        Meguid et al,    1988                            4               Gastrointestinal surgery (64)                             100                  TPNwith lipids 9 d before surgery
                                                70
                        Woolfson and Smith,        1989                 10               Thoracoabdominal surgery (122)                            . . .                TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                                71
                        Von Meyenfeldt et al,      1992                  7               Gastrointestinal surgery (101)                              29                 TPNwith lipids 10 d before surgery
                                        72
                        Yamada et al,     1983                           3               Gastric surgery (62)                                      . . .                TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                   73
                        Gys et al,    1990                               7               Colorectal surgery (20)                                      0                 TPNwith lipids after surgery
                                       74
                        Freund et al,    1979                            8               Gastrointestinal surgery (35)                                0                 TPNwithout lipids after surgery
                                   75
                        Sax et al,   1987                                8               Pancreatitis (54)                                         . . .                TPNwith lipids after admission
                                        76
                        Chiarelli et al,  1996                           6               Neurology ICU (24)                                        . . .                TPNafter admission; both groups received EN
                                                                                                                                                                           (unknown lipids)
                                        77 1989                          7               Burns on .50% of body (49)                                . . .                TPNwithout lipids after admission; both groups
                        Herndon et al,
                                                                                                                                                                           received EN
                          *Ellipses indicate data not available; EN, enteral nutrition; ICU, intensive care unit.
                          †Presented as mean ± SD or (range).
                          ‡No range was specified.
                          §Control group is the same for both criteria.
                        CI,0.49-1.95),therewasnodifferencein
                        mortality.(Pvalueforthedifferencebe-                                           65                                                        Holter and Fischer,68 1977
                                                                                             Abel et al,  1976
                                                                                                                68                                                            74
                        tween subgroups=.89). Complication                                   Holter and Fischer,  1977                                           Freund et al,  1979
                                                                                                         74                                                                       63
                        rates in studies that used lipids demon-                             Freund et al,  1979                                                 Thompson et al,  1981
                                                                                                             63                                                              33
                                                                                             Thompson et al,  1981                                               Muller et al,  1982
                                                                                                        33                                                                     72
                        stratednoeffect(RR,0.96;95%CI,0.69-                                  Muller et al,  1982                                                 Yamada et al,  1983
                                                                                                          72                                                     Brennan et al,61 1994
                                                                                             Yamada et al,  1983
                        1.34). In studies that did not use lipids,                                         61                                                                   62
                                                                                             Brennan et al,  1994                                                Askanazi et al,  1986
                                                                                                           62                                                                34
                        the complication rate was significantly                              Askanazi et al,  1986                                               Muller et al,  1986
                                                                                                        34                                                                 75
                                                                                             Muller et al,  1986                                                 Sax et al,  1987
                        lower(RR,0.59;95%CI,0.38-0.90).The                                            75                                                                        66
                                                                                             Sax et al,  1987                                                    Bellatone et al,  1988
                                                                                                            66                                                                         67
                        Pvalueforthedifferencebetweenthese                                   Bellatone et al,  1988                                              Smith and Hartemink,  1988
                                                                                                          69                                                               28
                                                                                             Meguid et al,  1988                                                 Fan et al,  1989
                        subgroupswasjustshortofsignificance                                                        67                                                           29
                                                                                             Smith and Hartemink,  1988                                          Figueras et al,  1988
                                                                                                      28                                                                              70
                        (P=.09).                                                             Fan et al,  1989                                                    Woolfson and Smith,  1989
                                                                                                           29                                                              73
                                                                                             Figueras et al,  1988                                               Gys et al,  1990
                                                                                                           77                                                                     27
                           Finally, we compared studies of criti-                            Herndon et al,  1989                                                Veterans Affairs,  1991
                                                                                                                  70                                                                  71
                        callyillpatientswithstudiesofprimarily                               Woolfson and Smith,  1989                                           Von Meyenfeldt et al,  1992
                                                                                                      73                                                                      32
                                                                                             Gys et al,  1990                                                    Hwang et al,  1993a
                                                                                                        31                                                                    32
                        surgical patients. The mortality rate of                             Reilly et al,  1990                                                 Hwang et al,  1993b
                                                                                                             27                                                            64
                        critically ill patients was higher among                             Veterans Affairs,  1991                                             Fan et al,  1994
                                                                                                                  71                                                           60
                                                                                             Von Meyenfeldt et al,  1992                                         Jimenez et al,  1995
                                                                                                         32                                                                    76
                        those receiving TPN (RR, 1.78; 95% CI,                               Hwang et al,  1993a                                                 Chiarelli et al,  1996
                                                                                                         32
                        1.11-2.85), while studies of surgical pa-                            Hwang et al,  1993b
                                                                                                             30                                                  Overall Risk Ratio
                                                                                             Sandstrom et al,  1993
                                                                                                      64
                        tients showed no treatment effect (RR,                               Fan et al,  1994                                                                              0.001 0.01 0.1       1    10 100
                                                                                             Jimenez et al,60 1995
                        0.91;95%CI,0.68-1.21).Thedifferencebe-                                            76
                                                                                             Chiarelli et al,  1996                                                                         TPN                         TPN 
                        tweenthese subgroups was statistically                              Overall Risk Ratio                                                                           Beneficial                   Harmful
                        significant(P=.03).Thecomplicationrates                                                        0.001 0.01 0.1       1    10 100                                        Risk Ratio (Log Scale)
                        inthestudiesofcriticallyillpatients(only                                                        TPN                        TPN 
                        2 studies reported complication rates)                                                        Beneficial                  Harmful        Figure 2.—Risk ratios and associated 95% confi-
                        showedatrendtowardanincreaseincom-                                                                 Risk Ratio (Log Scale)                dence intervals for the effect of total parenteral nu-
                        plications (RR, 2.40; 95% CI, 0.88-6.58),                                                                                                trition (TPN) on major complications.
                        whilestudiesofsurgicalpatientswereas-                               Figure 1.—Risk ratios and associated 95% confi-
                        sociated with lower complication rates                              denceintervalsforeffectoftotalparenteralnutrition
                        (RR,0.76;95%CI,0.48-1.0).ThePvalue                                  (TPN) on mortality.
                        for the difference between these sub-                                                                                                    the variability in duration of stay and
                        groupswassignificant(P=.05).                                        ported median stay and 9 reported                                    variabilityofreportingmethods,wedid
                           Only14studiesreportedtheeffectof                                 means.In8studies,thedurationofstay                                   notstatisticallyaggregatetheseresults,
                        TPNonduration of hospital stay; 5 re-                               wasshorterinthecontrolgroup.Dueto                                    buttheyaredisplayedinTable2.
                        2016 JAMA,December16,1998—Vol280,No.23                                                                             Total Parenteral Nutrition in the Critically Ill Patient—Heyland et al
                                                                                   ©1998AmericanMedicalAssociation. All rights reserved.
     Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 01/04/2023
The words contained in this file might help you see if this file matches what you are looking for:

...Caring for the critically ill patient total parenteral nutrition in ameta analysis daren k heyland md frcpc msc shaun macdonald frcsc laurie keefe rd john w drover context nutritional support has become a standard of care hospitalized barrier structure and function aug patients but whether tpn affects morbidity mortality menting inflammatory response to is unclear illnessandresultingingreaterinfectious objective examine relationship between complication as consequence nutri rates tional supporthasbecomeastandardof datasources computerizedsearchofpublishedresearchonmedlinefrom personal les review relevant reference lists because intestinal stimulation from study selection we reviewed titles abstracts papers primary luminalnutrientshelpsmaintaingastro mucosal func studies were included if they randomized clinical trials or surgi tion enteral may have some cal that evaluated effect compared with on advantage over complicationandmortalityrates weexcludedstudiescomparingtpnwithenteral ran d...

no reviews yet
Please Login to review.