jagomart
digital resources
picture1_Journal Pdf 98076 | Journal Club Template


 331x       Filetype PDF       File size 0.09 MB       Source: www.loyolamedicine.org


File: Journal Pdf 98076 | Journal Club Template
loyola surgery journal club article review template part 1 article nuts and bolts pgy1 or pgy2 name of journal journal impact factor author affiliations year of publication type of study ...

icon picture PDF Filetype PDF | Posted on 21 Sep 2022 | 3 years ago
Partial capture of text on file.
                                               
                                            LOYOLA SURGERY JOURNAL CLUB 
                                                ARTICLE REVIEW TEMPLATE 
                 
                PART 1 (ARTICLE ‘NUTS AND BOLTS’) – PGY1 or PGY2 
                Name of Journal:           
                 
                Journal Impact             
                Factor:  
                 
                Author affiliations:       
                 
                 
                Year of Publication:       
                 
                Type of Study (i.e.        
                RCT, retrospective 
                cohort review, meta-
                analysis, case 
                series): 
                 
                PART 2 (INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND) – PGY1 or PGY2 
                What is the knowledge   
                “gap” that is addressed 
                by the study? 
                Summary of previous           
                evidence (brief): 
                Revised 12/2017                                                                                     1 
                                         
              Objective/Hypothesis:     
               
              PART 3 (METHODS/STUDY DESIGN) – PGY1 or PGY2 
              Setting of the study (where and who     
              are the patients?): 
              Inclusion criteria:                     
              Exclusion criteria:                     
              Primary exposure/intervention:          
              Primary outcome:                        
              Secondary outcomes:                     
              Statistical/analytic approach:          
               
              PART 4 (RESULTS) – PGY 3+ 
              Final study population:                      
              Total excluded (and why):                    
              Baseline characteristics of population       
              (balanced? Significant differences?): 
              Summarize primary outcome:                   
              Summary of secondary outcomes:               
              Revised 12/2017                                                                      2 
                                         
              Summary of other relevant Tables or          
              Figures (including Supplementary data, if 
              relevant):  
              Author Conclusions:                          
               
              PART 5 (APPRAISAL OF STUDY) – PGY3+ 
              Does the research question have face       Yes/No 
              validity? 
              Are the authors equipped to conduct the    Yes/No 
              study? 
              Does the study design allow for answering  Yes/No 
              the stated objective?  
              Was the study population appropriate?      Yes/No 
              Were the inclusions/exclusions             Yes/No 
              appropriate? 
              Are there concerns with the statistical    Yes/No 
              methodology? 
              Are there problems with the sample size?   Yes/No 
              Were the groups comparable?                Yes/No 
              Do the study conclusions address the       Yes/No 
              stated study objective? 
              Do you agree with the authors'             Yes/No 
              conclusions? 
              Will this study change your clinical       Yes/No 
              practice?                                  Why or why not? 
                                                          
               
               
              Revised 12/2017                                                                     3 
The words contained in this file might help you see if this file matches what you are looking for:

...Loyola surgery journal club article review template part nuts and bolts pgy or name of impact factor author affiliations year publication type study i e rct retrospective cohort meta analysis case series introduction background what is the knowledge gap that addressed by summary previous evidence brief revised objective hypothesis methods design setting where who are patients inclusion criteria exclusion primary exposure intervention outcome secondary outcomes statistical analytic approach results final population total excluded why baseline characteristics balanced significant differences summarize other relevant tables figures including supplementary data if conclusions appraisal does research question have face yes no validity authors equipped to conduct allow for answering stated was appropriate were inclusions exclusions there concerns with methodology problems sample size groups comparable do address you agree will this change your clinical practice not...

no reviews yet
Please Login to review.